Driven by strong returns, private equity has seen unprecedented growth during recent decades. For example, a study by McKinsey & Co. showed that net asset values in private equity have outgrown public equities market capitalization nearly threefold since 2000. And the trend remains unbroken: in our Annual Investor Survey of private equity investors, 60% of them increased their allocations to the asset class in the past 12 months.
However, investing in private equity has its pitfalls. Generating large returns does not come without risks, because there is large dispersion in returns across buyout and venture capital (VC) managers. In a large sample obtained from Preqin, close to 10% of all buyout funds had negative returns, and more than 35% doubled their money. For VC, the loss ratio is much higher, as more than a quarter of VC funds return less than the invested capital and roughly 30% of funds have a multiple over 2x.
Deep knowledge of the asset class and strong selection skills are therefore of utmost importance for an investor that commits directly to buyout and VC funds. With substantial long-term experience, investors can make use of the right-skewed dispersion of private equity returns and benefit from it by generating returns higher than those of public markets.
Fortunately, secondary funds, which provide liquidity by buying the interests of existing funds, offer investors without that long-term experience access to the asset class, with similarly attractive return characteristics but with much lower-risk profiles. To illustrate the point, the following chart plots all of the internal rates of return (IRRs) for funds with vintage year 2015 or older from Preqin, clustered by their strategy. Blue dots below the orange line represent funds with negative IRRs. The rectangles show the lower and upper quartiles as well as the median (line in the middle).
The IRR for a secondary fund is comparable to that of a buyout fund, and it’s much higher than that of a VC fund. The dispersion, on the other hand, is much narrower: only 3 out of more than 200 secondary funds have IRRs below 0% — and only marginally so. The attractive IRR characteristics for secondary funds are the result of two key factors: First, secondary funds typically build up diversified portfolios of private equity funds — consisting of several dozen underlying assets — compared with much more concentrated buyout and VC funds. And second, as secondaries buy into existing private equity funds, it takes less time for them to receive distributions, which de-risks the funds much earlier.
The latter point is shown nicely by the above chart, which compares the median ratio of distributed to paid-in capital (DPI) for a fund, clustered by strategy and vintage year. As of the most recent valuation date of September 2021, secondary funds have consistently had the highest DPIs for each vintage year — except older vintage years, for which the longer holder period of buyout funds eventually translates into higher realized returns.
Take the vintage year 2016 as an example. A typical secondary fund has already returned more than 40% of the invested capital to its investors, whereas the DPI is less than 0.3x for a typical buyout fund. A typical VC fund has returned only 0.1x.
In summary, secondaries represent an attractive strategy for private equity investors — both experienced ones and investors new to the asset class who can build up their portfolios more quickly. Meanwhile, investors appreciate the mitigated J-curve and can profit from the appealing risk–return profile.
Read More
Read More
Read More
Read More
This website is intended for INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS located in France. Please set your preferences.
*Required Fields
Sorry based on your current selections, you cannot continue. Please update your selections or visit pgim.com/multi-asset-solutions for more information.
By continuing on to PGIM.com you are agreeing to the following:
This website is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice or an offer or solicitation in respect of any products or services to any persons who are prohibited from receiving such information under the laws applicable to their place of citizenship, domicile or residence.
For the purpose of France, the available information is limited to services, products and entities (and related documents) which are authorised for sale or to perform their activities in France. This Website is aimed only at professional clients (as defined by article D.533-11 of the French financial and monetary code) who understand English. This Website is not destined for non-professional clients.